I.
Did you see me trembling
under fury, caving under
knees too weak to rise
mind too lost to decipher
the chaos, the curses
they called truth?
What I thought--
did you know what I thought?
(you knew what I thought)
Was it apathy, then, indifference
keeping you silent as I struck
my iron chains against your
ancient lawless stones?
II.
I thought tyranny was divine:
thought creation yearned for order
and order enabled peace.
Hierarchy: the will of God.
I thought submission was freedom:
thought relinquishing gave life
and I, ever-willing, gave all.
Liberating. We don’t have to decide.
I thought recitation was voice:
thought opinion was doctrine
and doctrine my only right.
Listen, and you shall not depart.
I thought judgement was mercy:
thought honesty the truth
and truth must be brought to light.
Truth teller. I'm speaking the truth.
I thought cruelty was kindness:
thought love a monstrous force,
sometimes lulling, sometimes raging.
Love is hard. I am a hard man.
I thought pain was holiness:
thought looming clouds a gift
and despondent soul a charge.
Suffering. We are called to it.
I thought obedience was honor:
thought honor meant respect
and respect meant follow suit.
Honor your father and you will be blessed.
I thought silence was loveliness:
thought beauty bloomed in voids,
and withered on wagging tongues.
Precious, a gentle and quiet spirit.
I thought virginity was virtue:
thought the valued were untouched,
and the touched were never whole.
Shameful. Perception is reality.
I thought emotion was evil:
thought sensation was deceptive,
intuition a wayward guide.
Beware. The heart is wicked.
I thought suppression was liberty:
thought autonomy a sin,
and independence wretched conceit.
Authority. My spiritual right.
III.
I broke them. They fell
from my wrists and clamored.
Did it matter?
One child bound
another free. Did it matter?
God I don't know why it matters:
I think you saw me
and you let it be.
Unless (heresy)
you saw me
and that's why I'm free.
Wow! This really hits home to me. I was raised in a high-control religion. This line sounds like it was written for me personally:
“I thought submission was freedom,
thought relinquishing gave life
and I, ever willing, gave all—”
This line is like you were reading my mind:
“I thought suppression was liberty,
thought autonomy a sin,
and independence wretched conceit—”
Each “thought” shows how good is often weaponized to mask harm. I think that this should be read by anyone who has been raised to think suffering = holiness. Especially some of my family unfortunately.
Mark, I suppose we have a bit in common. Indeed, equating suffering and holiness is what it all seems to come down to. I am sorry you were raised with these thoughts as well and I hope you have found freedom beyond them. Thank you for your comment — it’s good to know every now and then we are not alone in our thoughts.